Wednesday, March 17, 2010
Answering Questions -- Mireyah Wolfe
The other day, my parents and I watched a movie called The Box. You might've heard of it--it's a film starring James Marsden and Cameron Diaz. They're a couple back in the 50's who receive a box on their doorstep one morning and a man comes and offers them a deal:
If they press the red button on the box, they will be given a million dollars.
Sounds awesome, right? But we all know there's always a catch.
If they press the red button on the box...someone in the world will die.
The general premise of this movie was really intriging. It's tension-filled, it makes you ask so many questions.
But I absolutely hated this movie. Why? Because it never answered my questions. I have no idea who was behind it all. I didn't find out what the final outcome was. I didn't see the main characters beat the "bad" guy. I saw one of the many couples who were offered this deal go the same exact route that the others had gone. This was not different except that they asked questions. They tried to figure it out. And they failed.
At the end of the movie, I knew what happened, but not because they told me. Not because they answered my questions. Because it was the only thing it could have been. Martians. (Yeah, I was shocked too: It's a total Sci-Fi movie.) (If you've seen the movie, you totally know what I'm talking about.)
How does this relate to writing?
One of the elements of writing a story is making your reader ask questions and want the answers. We want to know what will happen. Why it's happening. Who's doing it? Why are they doing it? How will the main characters win? Will they win? What will be sacrificed? What secret will be revealed?
The trick is making them ask these questions, and answer them as the story progresses...but giving them more questions to ask. Interweave the questions and answers until the climax...where there are no more questions, and the reader knows everything. (This is discounting series stories, which is a both a bit more complicated and simpler.)
The short of it is: Don't leave your reader hanging. It will make them hate you and the book.
(I just finished The Iron Hunt by Marjorie M. Liu and I'm very glad someone told me that it was a good set-up book because if they hadn't, I'd have been very upset over the lack of answers in it. Instead, I was prepared to still be asking questions, and I'm wanting the second one like you wouldn't believe.)
~Mireyah Wolfe
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Great post Mire. I never really considered watching that movies because the trailers didn't interest me and now I won't even waste my time. Part of writing a plot that is fun is the coming up with questions and then later solving them. Love when a beta reader asks about something that I know they will find out at the end of the book. Good times.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Dawn. Solving the questions is one of the best - and hardest - parts of writing. My challange is always deciding when to reveal the answers! I think timing is everything. You don't want to solve the questions too soon. Unless, of course, the answeres are more complicated than the reader thought and only leads to more questions!
ReplyDeleteReally good post Mireyah. I remember the trailer for that movie and I thought... GIMMICK. I sometimes let my mind wander and think, "What if...?" and wind up with some gimmick. What if the blue sky was actually the ocean and down was up and we were beneath/above it? The trouble is the almighty "why" question. These things don't just happen for no reason. Okay maybe the sky/ocean thing could just "be", but still.
ReplyDeleteMy problem is I sometimes leave the reader with TOO many questions along the way, and don't answer enough. I guess revising is about making sure "most" questions are answered, unless you've got a sequel to answer more.
Jay, I have that problem, too. *siiiiiiiigh*
ReplyDeleteI haven't seen that film! I guess I won't bother now that you've spoiled the ending. Thanks, mate!...lol...
ReplyDeleteYou've just reminded me, Mireyah, I need to get my eyes tested. I struggled to read that last part haha!!